Harry Potter Concept: Hagrid Was Voldemort’s Secret Loss of life Eater
A brand new idea means that Hagrid, probably the most beloved Harry Potter characters of all, might secretly have been certainly one of Voldemort’s Loss of life Eater. J.Ok. Rowling is undoubtedly one of many best literary abilities of the current day, and key to her success is her love of meticulous planning. Through the years, she’s developed a status for having each element of her tales deliberate out years earlier than she ever put pen to paper.
In fact, that status is slightly overstated. A essential eye will discover appreciable inconsistencies working by means of the Harry Potter books, reflecting the truth that Rowling by no means really realized how massive the phenomenon would grow to be, or how avidly followers would pore over each element in her novels. The traditional instance is Hagrid, who’s normally portrayed as a good-natured however ill-witted half-giant who bellows out secrets and techniques within the pub, however is someway nonetheless trusted with the small print of a lot of Dumbledore’s schemes. This type of inconsistency is an inevitable a part of the writing course of, particularly when a single creator has been engaged on an ongoing narrative for some 17 years; Rowling started writing the primary e-book in 1990, and the final was revealed in 2007.
Proceed scrolling to maintain studying
Click on the button under to begin this text in fast view.
Or is it an inconsistency? Or are they clues to Hagrid’s true nature? That is what Redditor Whoofph has impressively put ahead in his detailed idea that Hagrid may very well be a secret Loss of life Eater. It most definitely is not what J.Ok. Rowling meant, but it matches collectively extremely effectively.
How Hagrid As A Loss of life Eater Works
In keeping with this idea, Hagrid was really a part of Tom Riddle’s circle again once they have been at college collectively. Though Riddle in the end framed Hagrid for opening the Chamber of Secrets and techniques, the 2 remained involved over time, with Hagrid’s fascination with unlawful creatures that means they tended to function in the identical darkish magic circles. This led to Hagrid working as certainly one of Voldemort’s spies within the Order of the Phoenix in the course of the First Wizarding Battle, and secretly remaining loyal to the Darkish Lord even after his defeat.
It sounds a stretch, however there is a disturbing quantity of circumstantial proof. Firstly, in Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets and techniques a flashback reveals that Hagrid and Voldemort not solely attended faculty collectively – they have been on a first-name foundation. What’s extra, in Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, Hagrid explicitly tells Harry that Voldemort used to attend Hogwarts and even that he was a Slytherin again in his schooldays. That makes Hagrid certainly one of simply three non-Loss of life Eaters – the others being Dumbledore himself and Horace Slughorn – who related the good-looking and charismatic Tom Riddle with the monstrous Lord Voldemort. Hagrid even appears to point out a touch of information about Horcruxes, telling Harry that he would not know if Voldemort “had sufficient human left in him to die,” an unusual opinion amongst wizards that was remarkably near the reality.
Hagrid was one of many earliest members of the Order of the Phoenix, and took part within the First Wizarding Battle. He is hardly inconspicuous, however survived apparently unscathed, and certainly performed a key position on the finish of the battle. In Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, he was the primary to reach at Godric’s Hole after Voldemort killed the Potters, even beating the Muggle emergency companies. Given Hagrid cannot Apparate or fly a brush, and he solely picked up the motorcycle from Sirius whereas at Godric’s Hole, the logical clarification is that he was already shut by. In the meantime, it is fairly apparent that a number of the first wizards on the scene have been Loss of life Eaters, given Voldemort’s wand was saved after which given again to him when he ultimately returned to England. The speculation suggests Hagrid had been a deep-cover agent who was close to to Godric’s Hole on Voldemort’s orders, and rushed to the scene after the Darkish Lord’s defeat. He knew sufficient of Horcruxes to be assured Voldemort wasn’t really useless, and saved the wand earlier than taking the newborn Harry to the Dursleys.
Importantly, Hagrid is theorized to have remained loyal to Voldemort after his disappearance. He fastidiously positioned himself near Albus Dumbledore because the Keeper of Keys at Hogwarts, and developed relationships with senior figures within the Order of the Phoenix and the Ministry of Magic; in Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, Hagrid goes out for drinks with the Minister of Magic himself. And when Harry Potter arrives on the scene, after all, Hagrid steps up his sport.
Hagrid “Helps” Voldemort A Lot Throughout Harry Potter
Hagrid is the one who first tells Harry Potter that he is a wizard, and he goes to nice lengths to construct a detailed relationship with Harry and his pals. It is by no means portrayed as a very wholesome relationship, with Hagrid turning a blind eye to – and even encouraging – Harry’s breaking plenty of faculty guidelines. Ultimately, Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince invitations readers to query Hagrid, with the half-giant distraught as a result of the schoolchildren aren’t spending as a lot time with him. He begins to passive-aggressively guilt journey them, till they ultimately hunt down his firm once more.
The speculation posits that, because of his entry to each Harry Potter and to Albus Dumbledore, Hagrid regularly lets slip info that is essential to Voldemort’s plans. He is the one who tells Voldemort himself the way to get previous Fluffy in Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, and his recollection of these occasions is much clearer than you’d anticipate from somebody who was as drunk as he claims to be. In Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, he ensures Harry is aware of all about Thestrals, giving him a technique to get to London. And eventually, in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Hagrid does his stage greatest to sabotage the try to rescue Harry from the Dursleys’ home. He carelessly bellows Harry’s title a minimum of 14 instances, as if asserting to all of the world that he is with the actual Harry.
There are two notably fascinating examples that recommend Hagrid might have been working with Voldemort. The primary is in Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, when Hagrid chooses to take first years into the Forbidden Forest – and consequently units up a possible assembly between Voldemort and Harry. Then, in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Hearth, Hagrid conspires with Barty Crouch to make sure Harry wins the Triwizard Match. It is not arduous to ascertain that as a concerted effort handy Harry Potter over to Voldemort on a silver platter.
Hagrid’s Powers and Persona Are Inconsistent
To this point, the proof all appears circumstantial at greatest, and arguably runs counter to J.Ok. Rowling’s portrayal of Hagrid within the books. The issue, nonetheless, is that Rowling’s model of Hagrid is not precisely constant. For all Hagrid might have been certainly one of Dumbledore’s closest allies, he has a fairly harsh perspective in direction of Muggles; he performs unlawful magic on Dudley Dursley in Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, and repeatedly refers back to the Dursleys as “filthy Muggles” all through the whole collection. That appears to be the worst insult Hagrid might consider, which maybe testifies to his personal prejudices.
In the meantime, Hagrid’s regular bumbling and barely witless method is at odds along with his mission for Dumbledore in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix. When recounting the story of his adventures convincing the giants to facet with them within the warfare to Harry, Hagrid unwittingly demonstrates sturdy situational consciousness, sensible judgment, and a capability to barter and lie: he acknowledges skilled Ministry of Magic brokers who’re shadowing his staff, and deploys counter-surveillance strategies to throw them off; and, his negotiations with the Giants are carried out with a level of warning and empathy that is fairly exceptional, particularly when the journey ought to be an emotional one for Hagrid. This story ought to naturally lead readers to query whether or not there might be extra to Hagrid than meets the attention.
Even Hagrid’s powers are inconsistent. Hagrid is meant to have been banned from doing magic in his third yr, when his wand was snapped in half. And but, on his first look in Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, he performs a number of the most superior magic seen in the whole Harry Potter collection. He provides Dudley Dursley a pig’s tail, performing a non-verbal Transfiguration spell with a wand that is been snapped in half. Transfiguration is not taught till N.E.W.T. stage – Hermione was the one one in her class who managed to alter the colours of her eyebrows – and lots of wizards by no means grasp non-verbal magic in any respect. This, too, raises the likelihood that Harry and his pals by no means really get the measure of Hagrid.
Lastly, it is value noting that there are a handful of events the place Hagrid appears to get from place to position at uncommon pace, doubtlessly even possessing the facility of unaided flight. In Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, for instance, Hagrid collects Harry from a abandoned island and claims to have flown there. It is presumably Harry misheard, and Hagrid really mentioned “Floo,” however that is unlikely; there was just one cottage on the island, that means there have been no different fireplaces to hook as much as the Floo Community. Quick-forward to Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, and Hagrid claims to be too heavy to journey a brush or perhaps a Thestral. The most rational chance is unaided flight – which is a trick Voldemort taught to his closest Loss of life Eaters.
Why Hagrid As A Loss of life Eater Deepens Harry Potter
In fact, J.Ok. Rowling absolutely did not actually intend to suggest that Hagrid was a Loss of life Eater; Hagrid is just affected notably badly by the truth of the writing course of. When Rowling wrote Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, she had no concept how her world would evolve, and in consequence there are notable continuity points between this and the remainder of the Harry Potter story. In the meantime, the characterization points in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix are simply defined; Rowling suffered from extreme author’s block whereas engaged on that e-book, with the rising strain of the Harry Potter franchise weighing down upon her. Provided that context, a couple of narrative and characterization stumbles are to be anticipated.
However, assuming for a second that that is all true and that Hagrid is certainly a deep cowl Loss of life Eater working contained in the Order of the Phoenix, he turns into a much more complicated character, one whose story takes fairly a couple of twists and turns. Hagrid’s story culminates in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, the place he is mysteriously taken alive by the carnivorous Acromantulas. He is subsequently ordered by Voldemort to hold the physique of the Boy who Lived into Hogwarts Fort – and, curiously, this expertise appears to have been a key second in his life. The tears that streak down Hagrid’s cheeks as he carries Harry’s physique may be seen as tears of remorse, maybe indicating he’d come to genuinely look after Harry. That leads him to lastly take part within the Battle of Hogwarts, opposing Voldemort finally; though even then Hagrid focuses on a private grudge in opposition to McNair, who had tried to execute certainly one of his pets.
The fascinating query is whether or not or not Albus Dumbledore knew of Hagrid’s treachery. It is totally doable that Dumbledore suspected Hagrid and operated below the previous maxim of “hold your folks shut and your enemies nearer.” Dumbledore would absolutely leap on the alternative to have a recognized Loss of life Eater below shut statement, maybe unwittingly giving him perception into Voldemort’s plans. In the meantime, when Dumbledore lastly introduced Harry into the loop in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, he ensured spent much less time with Hagrid and was warned to not inform anybody what they have been doing. J.Ok. Rowling has all the time introduced Dumbledore because the supreme manipulator, and as such, it would not be a shock to see him issue a traitor into his plans.